Many Mithril Pages @ Faerylands

You are not logged in.

Announcement

           

#1376 Wed, Feb1 2012 2:27pm

Theobald
Wisest of Ents
From: the Osning in Germany
Registered: Tue, Jan29 2008
Posts: 5724
Website

Re: THE TAPROOM 2

Huuoommm ... Master Barliman, about that copyright and other right-thing I always thought, that GW has its rights from what you call "movie rights" (at least concerning the very early figures right after each part of the film trilogy was published). ...huom..
those first figures clearly referred in detail to the films (outward appearance and even facial expressions of some of the actors)... huooommm .... though even among those there were many figures I would ragard as being very disputable (avoiding the words "very bad") ... then the ranges were quickly expanded ... many more awful figures saw the light ... rhuuoommm ... it never came to my mind that MEE was in a position to accept or give a go for those figures .... huuooommm ... but, of course I don't know anything about such licence-things and the way some companies are involved in such matters and others seem to be not ... huuooommm ...
Huom ... unfortunately that development cought me in moments when I had a lot of time left and was keen on painting Mithrils again .... rhuuooommm ... but those were the days I call myself the "dark ages of Mithril" after all attempts (LR and LO series) failed and nothing new was in sight .... rhuoomm ... that's why in those days I bought many of those early GW-figures (yes, I do admit - mea culpa) just to have something to paint .... rhuuoommmm ....
huooommm ... when I had a look at the link you provided here laterly I know better now what the word disgusting could mean ... huoooooooooommm ... aaargghhhh ...

Offline

 

#1377 Wed, Feb1 2012 2:37pm

Theobald
Wisest of Ents
From: the Osning in Germany
Registered: Tue, Jan29 2008
Posts: 5724
Website

Re: THE TAPROOM 2

Huuoommm ... sorry, gentlemen, but I just witnessed that this serious discussion about language and linguistics still keeps on ... rhuoommm ... I did not want to interfere here, but wasn't aware of that while I was writing my last enty ... huomm ...and I'm not good at typing, you know ... huomm ... I just wanted to react to Master Barliman's comment about GW and MEE and things like that ... rhuom huomhom

Offline

 

#1378 Wed, Feb1 2012 3:10pm

Barliman
The famous Innkeeper
From: Bree
Registered: Tue, Jan29 2008
Posts: 4331

Re: THE TAPROOM 2

As far as I'm concerned the debate is over, Master Tree, and I'd rather talk about LOTR stuff anyway.

Yes, you're qute right about the early GW figures being true - indeed, accurate - to the movie artistry, while the latest stuff by contrast is....well, crap, for want of a kinder description. It doesn't look as if any of it is by the Perrys, which is where the problem is, of course; if it was by them it would at least be artistic, if not true to JRRT's vision (as I've said several times before, the GW figure sculptors' hands are tied to a great extent by having to adhere to what the company's so-called visualisers invent, and those guys were raised in the Fantasy with a capital F school of big-swords-and-heads-too-large-to-fit-a-shirt-over.

End product? Well, the link shows it. Most times that GW release some LOTR stuff there are at least a couple of figures that have some merit, but there's not a single one here that I'd even think about buying. Ever.


"A worthy man, but his memory is like a lumber-room: thing wanted always buried."

Offline

 

#1379 Wed, Feb1 2012 3:41pm

Theobald
Wisest of Ents
From: the Osning in Germany
Registered: Tue, Jan29 2008
Posts: 5724
Website

Re: THE TAPROOM 2

Huuuoommmm ... me too, Master Barliman ... and, as you pointed out, mind the price ... huoomm ... so many coiny-things for such ... err, "things" ... huoommm .... then I better spend some of my left coiny-things for a rat-tailed-scrumpy-liquid in your premises ... huoomm ... oh, err ... GW doesn't provide a barrel of scrumpy with rat tails hanging over the brim ... huom ... I can imagine you didn't give them a licence to do that, eh? ...

Offline

 

#1380 Wed, Feb1 2012 3:53pm

Barliman
The famous Innkeeper
From: Bree
Registered: Tue, Jan29 2008
Posts: 4331

Re: THE TAPROOM 2

Actually I'm surprised they haven't thought of it themselves. Perhaps we should have a word with The Man instead. It would make an interesting personalised MX concept.


"A worthy man, but his memory is like a lumber-room: thing wanted always buried."

Offline

 

#1381 Wed, Feb1 2012 9:15pm

cameosis
Master of Languages
Registered: Tue, Jan25 2011
Posts: 586

Re: THE TAPROOM 2

Barliman wrote:

Hmmmm. Debating the matter any further is clearly futile, Master Cameosis, since you're as dedicated to your viewpoint as I am to mine.

a fine closing statement, as it is on point. we’ll have to agree to disagree.

“to dis” means to bash or to insult someone—dict.org is a multilingual online dictionary. “dis” is also listed as colloquialism, by the way.

Barliman wrote:

It doesn't look as if any of it is by the Perrys, which is where the problem is, of course

the perry twins have turned to sculpting historical miniatures exclusively and have no plans of returning to the fantasy (pelennor) field.

Gildor Inglorion wrote:

we have the same problem with french being sometimes totally "raped" in its integrity under the banner of a "living tongue that has to evolve".... I personnaly am against such nonsense but that's my personnal opinion...

while i too am against the anglicization of many a language, i don’t believe that imposing french song quotas on radio stations is a very sensible or democratic way of preserving french, for instance … i do like the “organisation internationale de la francophonie.”

phonetic spelling would be wonderful, as it would mean that everyone could read and write. the orthography of the croat language is phonetic.

Theobald wrote:

Huuoommm ... sorry, gentlemen, but I just witnessed that this serious discussion about language and linguistics still keeps on ... rhuoommm ... I did not want to interfere here

the fault is all mine. but the lawyer and the troll in me got the better part of me this time. big_smile

Last edited by cameosis (Wed, Feb1 2012 9:17pm)


Esse quam videri. (Marcus Tullius Cicero)

Offline

 

#1382 Wed, Feb1 2012 9:49pm

Barliman
The famous Innkeeper
From: Bree
Registered: Tue, Jan29 2008
Posts: 4331

Re: THE TAPROOM 2

Interesting what you say about the Perrys. They're friends of mine (though I have to admit I haven't spoken to them lately) - do you mean they no longer work at GW? If they don't I'm very surprised indeed.


"A worthy man, but his memory is like a lumber-room: thing wanted always buried."

Offline

 

#1383 Thu, Feb2 2012 12:37am

cameosis
Master of Languages
Registered: Tue, Jan25 2011
Posts: 586

Re: THE TAPROOM 2

Barliman wrote:

Interesting what you say about the Perrys. They're friends of mine (though I have to admit I haven't spoken to them lately) - do you mean they no longer work at GW? If they don't I'm very surprised indeed.

that i can't tell (meaning i don't know, not that it's any kind of secret) -- but i had read on several miniature sites that they would stick to historicals, i.e. warhammer historical and their perry miniatures company -- they're very probably still with gw, but not doing fantasy anymore -- at least from what i had gathered.

here is a long interview from december 2009, also sharing info about the way the models for lotr came to be -- in short, they received instructions from weta, which was responsible for the character development and special effects in the movies et al.

http://www.battlegames.co.uk/documents/ … ridged.pdf

Last edited by cameosis (Thu, Feb2 2012 12:39am)


Esse quam videri. (Marcus Tullius Cicero)

Offline

 

#1384 Thu, Feb2 2012 8:27am

Barliman
The famous Innkeeper
From: Bree
Registered: Tue, Jan29 2008
Posts: 4331

Re: THE TAPROOM 2

That's quite an old interview. The reason I'm surprised by what you've suggested regarding  fantasy figures is that when I spoke to Michael last (in the autumn) he said they were already working on figures for GW's "Hobbit" range (and had also wangled themselves parts as extras in the movie, lucky beggars).

WETA were only responsible for the oiriginal film visualisations, and consequently the appearance of the first GW LOTR figures (Michael and Alan worked from WETA photographs, and also hands-on experience at the WETA "factory" - Michael wore the Sauron costume while it was being worked on for the film); GW's own visualisers have been responsible for the GW LOTR figure designs not actually based on the film characters.


"A worthy man, but his memory is like a lumber-room: thing wanted always buried."

Offline

 

#1385 Thu, Feb2 2012 2:32pm

cameosis
Master of Languages
Registered: Tue, Jan25 2011
Posts: 586

Re: THE TAPROOM 2

Barliman wrote:

WETA were only responsible for the oiriginal film visualisations, and consequently the appearance of the first GW LOTR figures (Michael and Alan worked from WETA photographs, and also hands-on experience at the WETA "factory" - Michael wore the Sauron costume while it was being worked on for the film); GW's own visualisers have been responsible for the GW LOTR figure designs not actually based on the film characters.

it still means that weta gave instructions on how the figures have to look like, not the zaentz company. tolkien sold the film rights to united artists, which in turn sold them to zaentz. in the end, new line acquired the rights to produce the film and thus can visualize the characters through weta as it sees fit.

see pages 19-21, including a graph, here:
http://books.google.de/books?id=CTrTPcK … mp;f=false


Esse quam videri. (Marcus Tullius Cicero)

Offline

 

#1386 Thu, Feb2 2012 3:09pm

Barliman
The famous Innkeeper
From: Bree
Registered: Tue, Jan29 2008
Posts: 4331

Re: THE TAPROOM 2

You've lost me. My point is that it's GW's visualisers who've been responsible for the appearance of ALL the non-movie-originated LOTR figures (i.e., characters, costumes, monsters and equipment not seen in the movies), NOT WETA - who've certainly never given GW "instructions on how the [non-movie] figures have to look". I know this from Richard Taylor himself, as well as the Perrys; I've even seen some of the GW visualisers' colour artwork that the figure designers have been obliged to work from - "All very bad," as JRRT would say. Somebody, not sure who, has to rubber-stamp it, I think, but I gather they've not changed anything that's been presented to them. Far too busy counting the dollars, I imagine.


"A worthy man, but his memory is like a lumber-room: thing wanted always buried."

Offline

 

#1387 Thu, Feb2 2012 4:16pm

Barliman
The famous Innkeeper
From: Bree
Registered: Tue, Jan29 2008
Posts: 4331

Re: THE TAPROOM 2

Ah, just seen the newsletter. Mauhur looks brilliant - whoever suggested it should be very pleased. I imagine that was our Orc-lover Shadyt, bless him. Shame that Beregond is delayed though.


"A worthy man, but his memory is like a lumber-room: thing wanted always buried."

Offline

 

#1388 Thu, Feb2 2012 4:37pm

Gildor Inglorion
Wandering Elf
From: Montpellier, France
Registered: Fri, Jan25 2008
Posts: 4098
Website

Re: THE TAPROOM 2

I just saw the sale about HD1 too.... 6,12€ here that's even CHEAP I'd say..that's a sale indeed but we're not used to such kind of generosity from mithril !


"Elves seldom give unguarded advice, for advice is a dangerous gift, even from the wise to the wise, and all courses may run ill." (Gildor Inglorion, LOTR1)

Offline

 

#1389 Thu, Feb2 2012 4:48pm

Barliman
The famous Innkeeper
From: Bree
Registered: Tue, Jan29 2008
Posts: 4331

Re: THE TAPROOM 2

Indeed.


"A worthy man, but his memory is like a lumber-room: thing wanted always buried."

Offline

 

#1390 Thu, Feb2 2012 4:58pm

Theobald
Wisest of Ents
From: the Osning in Germany
Registered: Tue, Jan29 2008
Posts: 5724
Website

Re: THE TAPROOM 2

Huuoooommm ... there seem to be some very nice Dunlending shield-design  in the HD2 ... rhuoomm ... close to the shield of the Dunlending chieftain in the old LR-series ... huoomm ... I'll see ...

Offline

 

#1391 Thu, Feb2 2012 5:07pm

Gavin
Skilled Artisan
From: Canada
Registered: Wed, Jan30 2008
Posts: 936

Re: THE TAPROOM 2

Yeah, the non-WETA visualisations are non-WETA, as it were.

GW just makes something vaguely like something they've already done and call it a day. And often have G. Morley sculpt it. Zaentz signs off on it, probably sight unseen (so long as it doesn't look eye wateringly horrible, they don't seem to care).

For contrast, Decipher made cards, using WETA costumes, of a lot of non-movie characters. The difference is pretty clear and poignant. (Also, check out the Hobbit trailer - we see the 2nd age High Elf armour show up again, as well as the Rivendell visualisation)

Offline

 

#1392 Thu, Feb2 2012 7:05pm

cameosis
Master of Languages
Registered: Tue, Jan25 2011
Posts: 586

Re: THE TAPROOM 2

Barliman wrote:

You've lost me.

well possible -- i meant the movie-based figures.


Esse quam videri. (Marcus Tullius Cicero)

Offline

 

#1393 Thu, Feb2 2012 8:48pm

Gildor Inglorion
Wandering Elf
From: Montpellier, France
Registered: Fri, Jan25 2008
Posts: 4098
Website

Re: THE TAPROOM 2

took some time tonight to add some picture from Thingol in the gallery and also update the database (I hear you saying "At Last!") with M520-524

I will add PCH7, PM4, and M525-529 when I hold them in my hands (for elements counting...)


"Elves seldom give unguarded advice, for advice is a dangerous gift, even from the wise to the wise, and all courses may run ill." (Gildor Inglorion, LOTR1)

Offline

 

#1394 Thu, Feb2 2012 9:32pm

Barliman
The famous Innkeeper
From: Bree
Registered: Tue, Jan29 2008
Posts: 4331

Re: THE TAPROOM 2

Theobald wrote:

Huuoooommm ... there seem to be some very nice Dunlending shield-design  in the HD2 ... rhuoomm ... close to the shield of the Dunlending chieftain in the old LR-series ... huoomm ... I'll see ...

Yes, they do look rather nice, don't they? I always rather liked the Dunlending chieftain's shield.


"A worthy man, but his memory is like a lumber-room: thing wanted always buried."

Offline

 

#1395 Thu, Feb2 2012 9:37pm

Barliman
The famous Innkeeper
From: Bree
Registered: Tue, Jan29 2008
Posts: 4331

Re: THE TAPROOM 2

cameosis wrote:

Barliman wrote:

You've lost me.

well possible -- i meant the movie-based figures.

It was GW's non-movie monstrosities that were under debate, not their movie-based figures, which is why you lost me. But not to worry. You'd probably just drunk too much scrumpy, which is why you weren't making sense. Scrumpy and troll just don't mix.


"A worthy man, but his memory is like a lumber-room: thing wanted always buried."

Offline

 

#1396 Fri, Feb3 2012 1:29am

cameosis
Master of Languages
Registered: Tue, Jan25 2011
Posts: 586

Re: THE TAPROOM 2

Barliman wrote:

You'd probably just drunk too much scrumpy, which is why you weren't making sense. Scrumpy and troll just don't mix.

i'll take another barrel then.


Esse quam videri. (Marcus Tullius Cicero)

Offline

 

#1397 Fri, Feb3 2012 8:38am

Barliman
The famous Innkeeper
From: Bree
Registered: Tue, Jan29 2008
Posts: 4331

Re: THE TAPROOM 2

For a little more money I could arrange a pipeline to your office.


"A worthy man, but his memory is like a lumber-room: thing wanted always buried."

Offline

 

#1398 Fri, Feb3 2012 12:59pm

cameosis
Master of Languages
Registered: Tue, Jan25 2011
Posts: 586

Re: THE TAPROOM 2

i'm positive my clients would love seeing the more "creative" legal translations that i'd churn out as a result ...


Esse quam videri. (Marcus Tullius Cicero)

Offline

 

#1399 Tue, Feb7 2012 5:14pm

Gildor Inglorion
Wandering Elf
From: Montpellier, France
Registered: Fri, Jan25 2008
Posts: 4098
Website

Re: THE TAPROOM 2

Has anybody received their Sauron figurine yet? sad

It seems my package was once again lost... and with it, the n°1 casting sad sad... it's the third time mithril packages do not reach me... and I only have problems with mithril about that...


"Elves seldom give unguarded advice, for advice is a dangerous gift, even from the wise to the wise, and all courses may run ill." (Gildor Inglorion, LOTR1)

Offline

 

#1400 Tue, Feb7 2012 5:52pm

Barliman
The famous Innkeeper
From: Bree
Registered: Tue, Jan29 2008
Posts: 4331

Re: THE TAPROOM 2

Perhaps someone in your local mail sorting office is also a Mithril collector - something similar happened with my mail once.


"A worthy man, but his memory is like a lumber-room: thing wanted always buried."

Offline

 

Board footer

Powered byPunBB
© Copyright 2002–2005 Rickard Andersson