Many Mithril Pages @ Faerylands
You are not logged in.
Announcement
#1 Tue, May12 2015 7:23am
- Tolwen
- Traveller
- From: Germany
- Registered: Mon, Nov8 2010
- Posts: 102
Goodbye GF
Hi all,
just FYI see this thread on the Mithril forum.
Cheers
Tolwen
Visit Other Minds Magazine, an unofficial magazine for roleplaying and academic interests in J.R.R. Tolkien's Middle-earth and beyond.
Offline
#2 Tue, May12 2015 7:42am
- Mornedhel
- Traveller
- From: Luxembourg province, Belgium
- Registered: Fri, Nov21 2008
- Posts: 668
Re: Goodbye GF
Sad 
However I share some points with your post.
I will just add that propose ideas is great but contribute to the conception and be listened is what I miss far more
________________________________
Elen silla lumenn omentilmo
Offline
#3 Tue, May12 2015 8:14am
- Tolwen
- Traveller
- From: Germany
- Registered: Mon, Nov8 2010
- Posts: 102
Re: Goodbye GF
Mornedhel wrote:
Sad
Indeed it is sad, but necessary IMO. Even now with not an hour ago I feel relieved and much better ...
I will just add that propose ideas is great but contribute to the conception and be listened is what I miss far more
This is included in the "design-wise" developments. I didn't think it appropriate to detail my - long - list of issues I have there, so I summed it all up under the "lack of development design-wise".
Cheers
Tolwen
Last edited by Tolwen (Tue, May12 2015 8:15am)
Visit Other Minds Magazine, an unofficial magazine for roleplaying and academic interests in J.R.R. Tolkien's Middle-earth and beyond.
Offline
#5 Thu, May14 2015 4:59am
- twrich
- The Man in the Dark
- From: Minneapolis, MN USA
- Registered: Tue, Jan29 2008
- Posts: 752
Re: Goodbye GF
Hi Tolwen, I will miss your suggestions. I also often vote for figures that have little chance of winning. But I've also had several produced, and sometime someone else is able to get one of my former suggestions into production. I understand interests change over time, but I do hope we hear from you once and a while.
"All that is gold does not glitter, not all those that wander are lost." (Strider, The Fellowship of the Ring)
Offline
#6 Thu, May14 2015 6:14am
- Arthadan
- Traveller
- From: Spain
- Registered: Fri, Nov6 2009
- Posts: 426
Re: Goodbye GF
Welcome to the Wandering Company Master Tolwen.
I was in your position many years ago, as I was part of the first Fellowship.
When the new one was formed, I was pretty excited but as I delved deeper into Tolkien lore the innacuracies of design, the high price and the huge variety of quality miniatures of other brands made me step aside.
Last edited by Arthadan (Mon, May18 2015 10:20pm)
To mortal fields say farewell,
Middle-earth forsaking!
In Elvenhome a clear bell
in the high tower is shaking.
Offline
#7 Fri, May15 2015 4:22pm
- Tolwen
- Traveller
- From: Germany
- Registered: Mon, Nov8 2010
- Posts: 102
Re: Goodbye GF
So I'll be in a Wandering Company? That doesn't sound too bad for me 
And the decision was not so much about changing interests (well, a bit but not that much), but about the final disillusionment about priorities at Mithril and C. Tubb (the old discussion...), whom I cannot share and therefore do not longer support. It was a long and not easy process, but in the end the cons outweighes the pros and thus I drew the consequence.
If they publish something I like, I may buy it, but beyond that there are companies out there with better value for money and better solutions for my priorities.
Cheers
Tolwen
Visit Other Minds Magazine, an unofficial magazine for roleplaying and academic interests in J.R.R. Tolkien's Middle-earth and beyond.
Offline
#8 Mon, May18 2015 12:33pm
- Maenas
- Traveller
- From: Barcelona, Catalonia
- Registered: Thu, Mar6 2008
- Posts: 572
Re: Goodbye GF
Oh, it is a pitty, but I perfectly understand and share some of the points you explain on mithril's website.
Was a very clean and polite post and should be taken into consideration, but I doubt they are going to forward your message...
---
Mae govannen mellon nín.
Offline
#9 Tue, May19 2015 9:47am
- Tolwen
- Traveller
- From: Germany
- Registered: Mon, Nov8 2010
- Posts: 102
Re: Goodbye GF
Maenas wrote:
Oh, it is a pitty, but I perfectly understand and share some of the points you explain on mithril's website.
Was a very clean and polite post and should be taken into consideration, but I doubt they are going to forward your message...
I am actually very confident that they (Mithril and C. Tubb) are convinced of doing the right thing by continuing the current path. Therefore yo're right. Fundamental changes for the better are highly unlikely.
Personally, I don't care anymore of whether Mithril continues in its (admittedly long-lasting) current undead state, becomes more alive or dies altogether. I'll take things as they come as a bystander on the sideline. I have more than enough material to paint and make dioramas from so I am quite relaxed on the further fate of Mithril 
Cheers
Tolwen
Last edited by Tolwen (Tue, May19 2015 2:55pm)
Visit Other Minds Magazine, an unofficial magazine for roleplaying and academic interests in J.R.R. Tolkien's Middle-earth and beyond.
Offline
#10 Thu, May28 2015 7:27am
- Barliman
- The famous Innkeeper
- From: Bree
- Registered: Tue, Jan29 2008
- Posts: 4331
Re: Goodbye GF
A shame indeed, but I'm not sure that "leaving" solves anything. If it makes you feel better, fine. But things will just carry on the same as before.
Things change very slowly here in the real world, if they change at all, and we all have views and opinions that not everyone shares. Personally I'm not a fan of several aspects of Chris' (or MERP/ICE's) figure interpretations, and as far as I'm concerned there are quite a few Fellowship figures that have nothing whatsoever to do with Tolkien's vision. But when that's the case I don't vote for them and I don't buy them. End of problem. I certainly don't expect everything or everyone else to change to suit my personal tastes - I don't even expect people to agree with my personal tastes - that would be unrealistic.
At the end of the day, as we say here in Bree, "you just have to grin and bear it."
"A worthy man, but his memory is like a lumber-room: thing wanted always buried."
Offline