You are not logged in.
I've already voted for young Gandalf, Master Elf.
As for the very old Mithril guys, I'm afraid that the 'Army of the Witchking' figures are too far in the distant past to be a practical proposition for a present-day wargame army. They're also Dol Guldur era rather than Minas Morgul era, which is what I'm looking for, and - to be honest - I'm not especially keen on them anyway (with all due apologies and vast amounts of respect to The Man).
Offline
Huooommmm ... I just heard a new rumour ... hom ... The new MX-metal-thing might see the light before those other knights that will follow..... huoomm ... suchwise being the first one bearing that (admittedly somewhat torn) standard ... hom ... the shape of it is new among Mithril-standards having been released so far .... rhuoommmm ...
Huommrhuoommm .... Master Barliman, is this tab of mine now being payed for by providing this rumour here first? ....
Offline
Good points on the uniforms...leaves me pondering. I think I need a refill....
Offline
Huoommrhuoommm .... right, I recognize it ... huomm ... tabroohommm it's called ... it has become more and more difficult to find this place here among all those other rooms ... huom ... I mean difficult to step into the right door ... hom ... anyway .... huomm ... I realize the Man in the Dark here, so I'm right at this place ... So why I called in is about Master Caster's idea of having oarsmen for a boat ... huommm ... or ship ... or vessel .... I like it very much .... hom.
So let those of us who are interested in building a corsair vessel support him ..... huoom.
Oh by the by where's Master Barliman? .... huomm ... I do hope he's well .... rhuoommm.
Offline
I'm here. I just haven't got any news to report at the moment, so I thought I'd just sit easy for a while.
Offline
If any of you has not yet voted for this month GF figurine, it's time for it currently it is a draw ... and well, I'd really like to see a Gandalf on eagle back
Offline
Huuoommmm ... I placed my vote days ago, Master Gildor .... rhuoomm.
Well, Master Barliman, as business isn't brisk around here I suggest to take a walk to the Mathom House .... huoommm ... I placed some new pics over there .... hom ... for a while ...
no time for a bowl of that clear clean water today .... I have to be busy .... rhuoommmmm.
Offline
Well I've been a bit busy trying to paint some Corsairs and get them finished before we go on holiday next weekend so I haven't had too much time to stop by.
Well master Elf, you must be knuckle-biting by now with the way the race is going. It just goes to show however that no matter how the first round ends the second round can be a whole lot different.
Anyhow, good luck.
David
Offline
huoommmrhuoommmmm .... I'm a bit undecided for some days .... keeps me thinking of the MX.
On the one hand this should be an MX (that means to be rare). So 100 castings will be sold by Mithril. .... huoommm ... Master Edman suggested to cast 200 of them figures ... rhuoomm ....
as I look at the members here I can count 20 ... the Gold-Fellowship believes to be about 250 ...
huoommm ... on the other hand I would like to keep that MX as it is ... rhuoomm ... some kind of rarity .... please comment about this .... thank you
Offline
well breaking the rules of the MX and creating more than 100 of each would create an "antecedent"...
Actually, if I remember well, you are free to choose the amount of figurines released (but you have to pay for the additional cost)... You would certainly have the whole GF interested in this anyway BUT, if an MX becomes a MS (except that only one person chooses it, and pays for it) then there is a conflict with MX and MS...
maybe a good solution would be to cast two batches, depending on how fast the first batch runs out. And only break the mould after that. If 100 figurines are sold out in less than a week, then cast a second AND LAST batch and THEN destroy the mould once and for all. This would assure quite a rarity closely related to the demand. These items are to become rare yes, but even the 1988 or 1989 christmas figurines which are now unfindable and very expensive, were cast in more than 150 copies.... Releasing 150 (+ the regular 30 for yourself) instead of 100 would also be a solution, but maybe 200 is a bit too much in a single batch.
Offline
I suspect if you cast 100 figures and sell them for 32 euros, you will sell them out really quickly. Everyone wants a rarity, and the MX figures are usually awesome.
I suspect there are 250 members of the Gold Fellowship and most of them probably buy the figures. Eventually. Most don't participate - its the same 20 or 30 people voting and suggesting. You'd probably shift more if the price point was lower. You'd also likely get more contributors to the forum and the voting if the price point is lower.
So if you made, say, 200 MX figures, then you can have a lower price point and more will sell. They just won't sell as fast.
My brain's a bit muddled this morning, but I suspect in the longer term, cheaper Fellowship/MX miniatures are the way to go. Make them double the price of their M equivalents.
But all this is purely academic unless Mithril finds a way of increasing its visibility and access to its products.
Gavin
Last edited by Gavin (Sun, Mar2 2008 5:28pm)
Offline
if MX "project" prices would lower from 2560€ to half the price, that would become indeed far much more reasonnable... But Mithril has to be sure the figurines are selling.... Hopefully, unlike when the MX project was created, the community of collectors and people interested in mithril "rarities" has grown up (if we look at the number of GF members) so changing the quantities per batch may be a solution... that's why my idea of 100+100 to check if it is selling... may be a good one and that will also serve as a "marketing analysis" for future MX, to create directly 200 figs, or keep on the 100 basis.
Offline
huommm .. thank you ... I would just like to give insight of sales strategy ... of the old 'Frumgar' there still are some to be sold down under ... we, the team, decided to have an extra-100 Frumgars casted for about 2,50 GBP/per figure ... they didn't sell in those numbers ....
That means there will not be 200 MX-Imrahils. But I know that those 100 will be sold out within a week, methinks. Sorry... I'll be back later on ...
Offline
Huuoommmm ... back again ... after having had supper ... rhuoommmm ...
I tend to accept Master Gildor's thoughts about this matter ... as they're close to mine.
MX cannot become an MS ... rhouuoommm ... in terms of metal-things or castings ... hom.
So there will be 100 Imrahils being sold by Mithril ... once they're casted.
Offline
Withour getting involved in all the convoluted maths (I have difficulty counting up the handful of coiny things in the till), that seems the simplest and most realistic solution to me.
Offline
Hello Master Ent,
Based upon the Frumgar experience, I would advise the 100 sold by Mithril plus the 30 to the sponsor(s). Although Gildor's idea would be nice, I doubt Mithril would make a first batch, and then start a second one later, at the option of the sponsor. they want to know up front what the production total will be so that they can advise buyers of the availability of the piece.
Also, although there may be some 250 GF members (which I believe means there have been 250 total since the begining of the GF, and some have registered more than once, not that there are currently that many, even counting those who don't vote or participate in the forums) there are still several dozens of Frumgars left to be sold out of 200 (not including the 30 numbered ones), and it has been well over a year since he was commissioned. This is even though Frumgar is being sold not just to GF members, but through an ebay store and is available to anyone worldwide!
In the case of an MX, of course, the sponsor can commission as many as they want, but I believe that it is rarity which makes an MX special.
Last edited by twrich (Mon, Mar3 2008 5:41am)
Offline
To talk about something else...
Well it seems that my eagle idea is flying away... and my "concept" of what a vignette month should be, is not shared at all with all members. Indeed vignettes are expensive, but they are rare among the MS choices to be made.
I must admit I am a bit disapointed (though nothing is lost yet)
The first vignettes released early during the first GF months had the true spirit of a vignette (Sauron vs Elendil/Isildur , the death of Boromir, the death of Thorin) Even in the MV series, the Death of Theoden, the Coming of Prince Imrahil... or former ones... all of them were true vignettes, with personnalities inside them.
But it seems that some think vignettes as "multiple figurines" or just a fighting scene not depicting events. I always thought that Vignettes should be events put into shape to capture an instant. And usually, this instand must be a strong one to deserve a vignette of its own (rather than a diorama made by collectors amateurs or professionals) something that deserves more than simple assembling of figurines but rather a whole as a sculpture.
I may be mistaken, but for those of us, if there are any, who love vignettes... they are too scarce , I think, to suggest a vignette which is just a juxtaposition of two or more single figurines, most of all, anonymous ones. Indeed, anybody has rights to submit mounted, single figurines too. But when it comes to suggesting vignettes I think it would be cool to have them, real vignettes with "names among them"
Offline
Gildor Inglorion wrote:
To talk about something else...
Well it seems that my eagle idea is flying away... and my "concept" of what a vignette month should be, is not shared at all with all members. Indeed vignettes are expensive, but they are rare among the MS choices to be made.
I must admit I am a bit disapointed (though nothing is lost yet)
The first vignettes released early during the first GF months had the true spirit of a vignette (Sauron vs Elendil/Isildur , the death of Boromir, the death of Thorin) Even in the MV series, the Death of Theoden, the Coming of Prince Imrahil... or former ones... all of them were true vignettes, with personnalities inside them.
But it seems that some think vignettes as "multiple figurines" or just a fighting scene not depicting events. I always thought that Vignettes should be events put into shape to capture an instant. And usually, this instand must be a strong one to deserve a vignette of its own (rather than a diorama made by collectors amateurs or professionals) something that deserves more than simple assembling of figurines but rather a whole as a sculpture.
I may be mistaken, but for those of us, if there are any, who love vignettes... they are too scarce , I think, to suggest a vignette which is just a juxtaposition of two or more single figurines, most of all, anonymous ones. Indeed, anybody has rights to submit mounted, single figurines too. But when it comes to suggesting vignettes I think it would be cool to have them, real vignettes with "names among them"
Mae govannen mellon Gildor,
I think you are perfectly right: GF figures or vignettes should be something very special, BUT also something one can pay- I like the Sauron vignette very much, but it was hard to pay such a high price for this:/. Me too does not like the idea of GF figures which could be easily "normal" M- figures. BUT: who decides about that?
NAMARIE
estel
Last edited by ESTEL (Mon, Mar3 2008 11:36am)
Offline
I know my point of view cannot be shared by many alas. Maybe I'll submit a MX one day... It happens that I have a budget allocated especially for Mithril still Sauron vignette was expensive far much thant anticipated (I don't think any of us could know what price such a vignette could reach at the time of its vote... Since then people are -and this is very normal- quite afraid figurines may reach a big price...
Oh by the way I don't always submit expensive ideas Cirdan was my idea too and well, it was just a single figurine.
What saddens me the most is... vignette or single or any kind of GF release... is when the "theme" is not "special". For example, the corsair Admiral, it is a cool figurine indeed, but it could have been casted along with the corsairs of Umbar regular M series... Now if you want the whole corsairs fleet, you have to be a member of the GF..... which is a bit odd. and though the corsair admiral is very well sculpted.... I admit I did not vote for it because I did not see its relevance among GF "specials".... same for lossoth hunter, female ranger or troll drummeror trhanduil's standard bearer...
but once again, everbody is free and the general vote proved me wrong on my "way of thinking"
Offline
What makes a figure a 'special' is when you can't get it in an ordinary 'M' range. And the slowness with which new 'M' ranges appear means that if anyone wants a particular figure then the Fellowship vote (or an MX project!) is the only way to get it.
Though my own preferences will always be for characters from the books (which is why I voted for Gandalf this time round), I've no objections to anyone suggesting anything at all - I don't have to vote for it if I don't want to, and don't have to buy it if it doesn't appeal to me.
Offline
well that's all too true barliman... Fact is that people submit - what should otherwise be considered common - figurines because the regulard range is too... slow to be released and satisfy people. So if people have some figurines they'd like to see released, they use the GF system to accelerate the process of release... but in the end, that's not really satisfying for anybody... Either the diorama maker who needs variants, the army make who'd require several types of a same "theme", and the collector, who will anyway buy a figurine for his collection to keep it complete though he does not like it.
Let's look at the lossoth example : some people would gladly like a full range of lossoth, the same way some wanted a range of corsairs. It happens that the corsairs were soon to be released (which was unknown at the time of the vote) and so, it could have been a regular release. So people tend to suggest and vote for things they'd like to see released, no matter if it is special or not....
Maybe We should suggest to Mithril that future M series be announced quite some time before (providing TE accepts it) and that would help us choose wether or not to suggest something in the GF system...
Or maybe extend GF power to vote which future release we would like to see released, among a list of choices Mithril would give us. That would be a good idea.
I doubt there are any GW spies around here that would inform GW about what Mithril plans to do in order to counter Mithril and create problems with TE licensing... that would really be ... childish and unproductive , as for sure all of you will agree.
Maybe this "vote" could only be accessed via the GF boards so that it is not public and require some seriousness as well as not to risk a leak towards GW.
Offline
Hear hear Master elf. "and the general vote proved me wrong on my "way of thinking" "
Einstein had a very "wrong" way of thinking and he proofed all the others wrong....
Stay with your way of thinking, you are not alone..
Master Ent, I would not recommend to cast 200 MX, exept you want to keep 50 for yourself, or sell them over the next years....
250 GM does not mean 250 figures will be sold. It is a lttle bit like MMP. Aprox 160 members on the old MMP site. 24 now on the new one, wow very impressive. But it is good, a clean up was needed. I'm sure if you would take out all the members of the GM with no aktivite for the last 4 months, ther wouldn't be to many left eighter. Maybe 50 to 60. We only had 41 voting this month and this was more then usual.
Offline
thinking about MX... i have some questions for master Ent
The official page mentions 30 high quality figures + broken mould to be sent to sponsor. Actually that's quite different from what has been done so far (100+30 and only picture of mould) I was wondering if the Price the sponsor had to pay for this "difference" was significant? Actually, ~2500€ was for 30 figurines or for 100+30 with 100 being sold by Mithril for their income only? Or is the price less expensive, if you choose to have those 100 made and sold with 100% benefits for Mithril, as it is certain to sold out...Could you please give me some info about it master ent? (if you prefer to answer privately I'll understand of course)
Holger, once the database is complete... and damn i am overwhelmed at trying to complete it... and the gallery a bit more furnished... I will advertise a lot for this site... and add its link for mithril official website, that may result in a lot of people coming here... out of curiosity at first... And I found several people who were interested, not knowing about this community, and who should appear any time soon on the mailboard.
Also, please note that in the links section of mithril.ie, mmp.perilousrealm.com still appears there, and is referenced though it does not exist anymore. Maybe we should contact mithril telling them to switch the description and the link to this site instead, and cancel the old link....
Offline
Nice to hear, that there are more people out there interested in Mithril.
Regarding MX, it always was only 30 minis for Euro 2500.00. Mithril changed only the part with the mould. First they wrote 30 minis + mould. After I asked for the mould they told me the mould has to be destoid, broken. So they cut the mould in two halfs send me the pic from the mould.... and guess what...I'm still waiting for the mould and the masters to arrive at my place.
Every added number of figures more then the 30 you have to pay for. the more you buy the cheaper becomes the single mini. Just not so good if you order 500 minis and your kids will still have some to sell.
Offline
then you mean that the 100 more that Mithril is selling for collectors... do exist courtesy of the funds of the sponsor? If a sponsor would or could not afford to pay the "surplus" for these 100 there would not be any of them?
which means that in the end, it cost far much more than 2500€ ?
Offline